You are here: Home > Blog > 6 Local Favorites: Pizza on the Forgotten Coast

6 Local Favorites: Pizza on the Forgotten Coast

By Forgotten Coast Web Team | September 10, 2021

Pepperoni Pizza

Are you looking for a good slice of pizza? With so many unique and fun things to do here, a slice at the end of the day is just icing on the cake! Lucky for you, a good pie is not hard to find on the Forgotten Coast.


BJ’s Pizza and Subs is classic St. George Island. They’ve been putting out delicious pies since 1990, and with a lovely outdoor deck, a game room, local beer, and delicious sandwiches and salads, it’s no wonder they are still the local island hang-out. Locals will tell you that their ranch dressing is so delicious it’s drinkable and perfect for pizza crust dipping.

Beer and Pizza at BJ's Pizza on St. George Island

Vincenzo’s Eastpoint Pizza Company

Don’t worry if you get hungry hanging out at the Eastpoint Beer Company. Notice the big boat in the side lot. Well, there is a pizza oven in there. Vincenzo’s thin-crust pizzas are baked to perfection and will wow you. Feel free to order a slice or get a whole pizza to go. Vincenzo’s also offers a limited delivery service and the option to order online for 5% off!

Pizza and Beer at Vincenzo's Eastpoint Florida

Up to No Good Tavern

Up to No Good is on the second level of one of Apalachicola’s historic buildings in the center of town. This lively pizza place is a 21 and over establishment that also offers small-plate dining and a full menu dining room. They have a full bar with TVs and an outer deck for those wanting to gaze out onto the Apalachicola Bay and charming downtown Apalachicola.

Up to No Good Tavern in Apalachicola, Florida

98 Eats

Next door to Bar 98 in Eastpoint, 98 Eats is a popular newbie to the pizza scene. Newbie or not, the pizza gets raving reviews. And, if you are trying out one of those crazy low-carb diets, 98 Eats offers a crustless pizza! You won’t go wrong with ordering pizza to dine-in or take-out at 98 Eats.

98 Eats in Eastpoint Florida

Marine Street Grill

Carrabelle has a pizza hot spot with a beautiful courtyard and TVs so everyone can watch the game while they enjoy delicious pizza. Located on Marine Street in Carrabelle, Marine Street Grill offers classic pizzas like the Classic Roni and new favorites like the LaBelle, a pizza with local shrimp. And, of course, if pizza isn’t your thing, they have various salads, sandwiches, wings, and burgers.

Marine Street Grill in Carrabelle Florida

Sopchoppy Pizza Company

Carrabelle’s newest pizza place has delicious pizza and plenty for the one person in your crowd who doesn’t eat pizza. They even have gluten-free pizza! The Sopchoppy Pizza Company is also known for legendary handcrafted burgers, sandwiches, and desserts!

Sopchoppy Pizza Company in Carrabelle Florida

Everything is better with pizza, including vacations! Check out all our pizza joints and other restaurants here